Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Moved the bulk actions spec to build-ready after 3 rounds of critique.

Interpretation

Outcomes are there but stated loosely; the reader has to infer the size of the impact. Target approached: Delivered results tied to a metric or clear outcome.

Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Ran 5 usability sessions; the main finding was people miss the save action, so we are testing a sticky footer.

Interpretation

The gap surfaced after execution rather than through a planned check. That falls short of the required quality bar.

Coaching

Define the completion check before starting and record whether it passed before hand-off.

Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Moved the bulk actions spec to build-ready after 3 rounds of critique.

Interpretation

Saw what needed doing and did it — no waiting for direction. Target hit: Takes problems end-to-end without being asked.

Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Ran 5 usability sessions; the main finding was people miss the save action, so we are testing a sticky footer.

Interpretation

The work stayed within the individual lane, with no reusable help or shared learning. That misses the criterion’s team-elevation requirement.

Coaching

Share the method from this work with one teammate and record what it helped them unblock.

Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Moved the bulk actions spec to build-ready after 3 rounds of critique.

Interpretation

The risk was recorded after it affected the work rather than when action was possible. That falls short of honest, timely communication.

Coaching

Surface the risk when it first appears and state the decision needed in the opening sentence.

Score

Comparison

Not enough prior data for a baseline comparison.

Evidence

Ran 5 usability sessions; the main finding was people miss the save action, so we are testing a sticky footer.

Interpretation

A next step is mentioned without a hypothesis or decision rule. That approaches reflection but not the required experiment.

Coaching

Write the hypothesis and decision rule before the next attempt.